Seller Guides · San Diego

Selling a Home When You Owe More Than It’s Worth in San Diego

Selling a home when you owe more than it’s worth in San Diego is not a failure, it is a situation with a path through it. Here is how to run the real numbers, when to wait, and how bringing cash to closing, a short sale, and California’s anti-deficiency rules actually work.

Quick Answer

Yes, you can sell a home when you owe more than it’s worth in San Diego. Start with one honest calculation: today’s realistic market value, minus your mortgage payoff, minus any other liens or a HELOC, minus your seller closing costs. That tells you whether you are actually underwater, close to breaking even, or still holding a little equity. Then answer two questions: do you have to sell, or do you want to sell? If you do not have to sell, waiting, paying down the loan, or renting may be the better path. If you do, the main options are bringing cash to closing to cover the gap, a lender-approved short sale, or working with your lender before foreclosure becomes a risk. In California, a lender that approves a short sale on a one-to-four-unit home generally cannot pursue you for the balance, but the federal tax break for forgiven mortgage debt expired at the end of 2025, so the plan should be built with the right professionals.

4 yearsStandard Fannie Mae wait for a new conventional loan after a short sale or deed in lieu
7 yearsStandard Fannie Mae wait after a completed foreclosure
580eCalifornia rule barring a deficiency after a lender-approved short sale on a one-to-four-unit home
Jan 1, 2026Federal exclusion for forgiven primary-home mortgage debt expired for new discharges

Sources: Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-5.3-07; California Code of Civil Procedure Section 580e; IRS Publication 523 and Congressional Research Service. General information, not legal or tax advice.

Are you actually underwater? Run the real net numbers

If you owe more on the home than what the home is actually worth, that is what people usually call being underwater. And first off, I want to make sure you understand this is not a failure. It is a situation. Sometimes it happens because of the market. Sometimes it happens because values have shifted. Sometimes it happens because the home was purchased at a certain time, or there are other liens, loans, or costs attached to the property.

So the first thing I want to do is get real numbers in front of us. I want to know exactly what your mortgage payoff is, whether there are any additional liens, whether there is a HELOC, and what the seller closing costs would look like. Then we compare that number to what the home could realistically sell for in today’s market:

The real net number

Current market value, minus the mortgage payoff, minus any other liens, minus the seller closing costs. That gives us a more accurate picture of where you really stand. My San Diego home sale proceeds calculator runs this math for you, including the county transfer tax and escrow costs, and shows the shortfall if there is one.

A worked example: close to value, still short

Here is how a home can be worth almost exactly what is owed and still come up short at closing. The numbers are round and simplified to show the math, not a quote for your home.

Line itemAmount
Realistic sale price$850,000
Mortgage payoffminus $845,000
San Diego County documentary transfer tax, $0.55 per $500minus $935
Escrow, title and other fees, about 0.65%minus $5,525
Before any commissions$1,460 short
Commissions and any buyer agent compensation, as negotiated in your agreementswidens the gap dollar for dollar

On paper this owner has $5,000 of equity. In reality the sale cannot close without cash, a lender-approved short sale, or a different plan. Put your own payoff, commission and costs into the home sale proceeds calculator to see your real number in about two minutes.

That last item, the cost to sell, is where a lot of homeowners get surprised. On paper, a home can be worth about what the owner paid, and once commissions, closing costs and any buyer credits are in the math, the sale can still come up short. So we ask three questions. Are you actually underwater? Are you close to breaking even? Or is there still a little bit of equity there once we look at the full picture?

Why I am seeing more of this from 2023 and 2024 buyers

This is my own read, not a market statistic, but I am starting to see more homeowners who bought in 2023 and 2024 end up a little underwater. In my opinion, a lot of those buyers were buying under the “date the rate, marry the house” idea, with the expectation that rates were going to come down and they could refinance. Rates have not come down the way a lot of them expected. So some people who bought at those higher prices, and never got the refinance they planned on, are now sitting slightly underwater once the cost to sell is in the math. If that sounds like you, you are not alone, and it is exactly why we start with real numbers. For the buyer side of that decision, see should buyers wait for rates to drop in San Diego.

Because sometimes people think they are underwater, but once we look at the real numbers, they may still have a small profit. And sometimes it is the opposite. That is why we do not want to guess. For a sense of where values are today, my San Diego real estate market update has current county, ZIP and neighborhood figures, and how to price your home to sell in San Diego explains how I set a realistic number.

Do you have to sell, or want to sell?

After we understand the numbers, I have two important questions: do you have to sell, or do you want to sell? Because those are two very different situations.

You want to sell

  • If the numbers do not make sense today, pausing may be the better path
  • Time lets the loan balance come down and the market improve
  • Renting can work if the rent covers most of the carrying costs
  • Avoid forcing a sale when the numbers do not support it

You have to sell

  • A move, a job change, a divorce or a hardship can take waiting off the table
  • Bringing cash to closing is the cleanest exit if you have the funds
  • A short sale needs lender approval and more time
  • Acting early keeps more options open

If you do not have to sell: wait, pay down, or rent

If you do not have to sell, my recommendation may be to pause and look at other options. Maybe you wait and build more equity. Maybe you continue paying down the loan balance. Maybe renting the property makes sense if the rent can cover most or all of the mortgage, taxes, insurance, and expenses. That might give you more time for the loan balance to come down and for the market to improve. And if we can avoid forcing a sale when the numbers do not make sense, that may be the better path.

Renting is a real commitment, not just a holding pattern. San Diego and Chula Vista both have tenant protection rules that shape what happens when you do eventually sell, which I cover in how to sell a home with tenants in San Diego.

Can you sell a house for less than you owe?

Yes. But if you do have to sell, then we need to talk through your options.

Bring cash to closing

One option is bringing cash to closing to cover the gap. For example, if the home sells and there is a $10,000 shortage between the sale proceeds and what is owed, then you may need to bring that $10,000 to the table in order to close. That money could come from savings or another source, but that is something you would want to think through carefully and discuss with your lender, financial advisor, or whoever is helping you make those decisions.

The benefit of that option is that the property gets sold, the mortgage gets paid off, and you are able to move forward without the property hanging over you.

A lender-approved short sale

Another option could be a short sale. A short sale is when the lender approves the property to be sold for less than what is owed on the loan. That is not something I can guarantee, and it is definitely something that needs to be discussed with the lender. There may also be credit, tax, or legal consequences, so I would always recommend getting the right professional guidance before going down that path.

If the mortgage is one of several debts you are struggling with, talk to a California bankruptcy attorney before you sign a short sale or a deed in lieu. Bankruptcy is not the right answer for most sellers, but the order you do things in can matter, and that is a legal question, not a real estate one.

Not sure where you really stand?

Before you assume the worst, let’s run the real net numbers on your home: value, payoff, liens and the cost to sell.

How a short sale works in San Diego

A short sale follows the same basic path as any listing, with one extra decision-maker: the lender. That process can take longer because the lender has to review the situation, approve the sale, and agree to accept less than the full payoff. In practice:

  1. Get the numbers and talk to the lender early. Payoff, any second loan or HELOC, and the realistic sale price.
  2. Prepare the hardship package. Lenders generally want to understand why you need to sell and review your finances.
  3. List at a realistic price and find a buyer. The offer is accepted subject to lender approval.
  4. Lender review. The lender, and any second lienholder, reviews the file, looks at value, and approves or counters the price and terms.
  5. Close with written approval. The approval letter should spell out how the remaining balance is handled.

How long does a short sale take?

Longer than a standard sale, and the lender sets the pace. The timeline depends on the lender, how many liens are involved, and how complete the file is when it arrives, which is why starting early and having the documents ready matters. Any buyer on a short sale has to be comfortable waiting for that approval.

Every lien has to sign off

A short sale only works if every party with a claim on the property agrees to release it. That includes the first mortgage, any second loan or HELOC, and can include an HOA lien, a tax lien or a judgment lien recorded against the home. A second lienholder often asks for a payment out of the sale to release its lien, and the first lender has to agree to that amount. Order a preliminary title report early so every lien is on the table before you list.

What the approval letter should say

  • The exact amount the lender agrees to accept from the sale
  • That the lender accepts it in full satisfaction of the debt
  • That any deficiency is waived, for every borrower on the loan
  • That the remaining balance will not be sold or assigned to a collector
  • A matching approval from every other lienholder

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau advises getting any deficiency waiver in writing and keeping it for your records. Have a California real estate attorney read the letter before you close.

Short sale vs. foreclosure: credit and buying again

A short sale is a voluntary sale you arrange with the lender’s approval. A foreclosure is involuntary: the lender takes the property after missed payments. Both affect your credit and your ability to buy again, but not equally. Under the Fannie Mae Selling Guide section on waiting periods, the standard wait before a new conventional loan is four years after a short sale or deed in lieu of foreclosure, compared with seven years after a completed foreclosure, and documented extenuating circumstances can shorten both. FHA, VA and other programs have their own rules, so the lender you would use to buy again is the one to ask.

Deed in lieu and lender workouts

A deed in lieu of foreclosure is when you voluntarily transfer the property back to the lender instead of going through foreclosure. Loan modifications, repayment plans and forbearance are other tools that can restructure the loan or defer payments. Each is a direct conversation with your lender, and each works far better when it starts early.

Will you owe the difference? California anti-deficiency law

What California law says

Under California Code of Civil Procedure Section 580e, once a lender approves a short sale of a dwelling of one to four units, it generally cannot pursue the borrower for the unpaid balance, and the same applies to a junior lienholder that consents to the sale. Section 580b protects many purchase-money loans on owner-occupied one-to-four-unit homes, and Section 580d generally bars a deficiency after a non-judicial trustee’s sale. There are exceptions, such as fraud, and refinances, second loans and non-purchase-money debt can change the analysis. I am a licensed Realtor, not your attorney, so confirm how these apply to your loans with a California real estate attorney.

Taxes on forgiven mortgage debt in 2026

The federal exclusion expired

For years, the qualified principal residence indebtedness exclusion let homeowners exclude forgiven mortgage debt on a primary home from federal income. It was last extended through the end of 2025, and IRS Publication 523 notes the discharge must generally be based on a written agreement made before January 1, 2026. A bill to make it permanent has been introduced in Congress but has not become law. So forgiven debt can now be taxable, though the insolvency and bankruptcy exclusions still exist, and debt that is non-recourse under California law can be treated as a sale rather than forgiveness. California has its own rules. This is technical and fact-specific, so run it with a CPA before choosing a path.

Expect paperwork either way. When a lender cancels debt it can file Form 1099-C with the IRS and send you a copy, even when California law stops it from collecting the balance. IRS Publication 4681 explains how canceled debt is treated, including the difference between recourse and nonrecourse loans and the insolvency exclusion, which is claimed on Form 982.

Act early if foreclosure is a concern

If you are in a situation where foreclosure is a concern, then we also need to act early. Sometimes there may be options like a loan modification, repayment plan, or forbearance. That is a conversation directly with your lender. They may be able to restructure the loan, defer certain payments, or offer another solution depending on your situation.

But the biggest thing is that we do not want to ignore it. The worst-case scenario is falling behind, not communicating with the lender, and letting the property move toward foreclosure without a plan. Foreclosure can negatively affect your credit and your ability to buy again in the future, so if there is a way to avoid that, we want to explore the options as early as possible. If you are already behind, my guide on selling your house in pre-foreclosure in San Diego covers the timeline and options.

Free help from a HUD-approved housing counselor

HUD funds free or very low-cost housing counseling, and a HUD-approved counselor can help you talk to your lender about a modification, repayment plan or short sale. Call (800) 569-4287 or use HUD’s avoiding foreclosure page to find a counselor near you in San Diego County.

At the end of the day, the biggest thing is getting clear on the numbers. What is the home worth today? What is owed? What are the costs to sell? Is there a gap? And if there is a gap, is there a realistic path to cover it?

How I help when you owe more than it’s worth

Being underwater is not a failure on your part. It is a financial situation, and the goal is to slow down, look at the facts, and make the best decision with the information we have. My job is to help you understand your real estate options, walk you through the numbers, and help you figure out the cleanest path forward. Whether that means selling now, waiting, renting it out, talking to the lender, or exploring a short sale, we will start with the numbers and build the plan from there.

You can read what past clients say about working with me on my client reviews page, and the complete guide to selling your home in San Diego covers the full process.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sell my house for less than I owe?

Yes. If the sale comes up short of your payoff, you can bring cash to closing to cover the gap, which gives you a clean exit. Or you can pursue a lender-approved short sale, where the lender agrees to accept less than the full balance. Which path fits depends on the size of the gap, your finances and your timeline.

What does it mean to be underwater on my home?

Being underwater means you owe more on your mortgage and any other liens than the home is currently worth. It is a financial situation, not a failure. It can happen because of the market, a shift in values, when the home was purchased, or other liens, loans or costs attached to the property.

How do I know if I am actually underwater after selling costs?

Run the full math: the realistic market value today, minus your mortgage payoff, minus any other liens or a HELOC, minus your seller closing costs. Sometimes people think they are underwater and still have a small profit. Sometimes it is the opposite, and the costs to sell create a gap even when the value is close to what they owe.

What is a short sale?

A short sale is when the lender approves the property to be sold for less than what is owed on the loan and agrees to accept those proceeds. It takes longer than a standard sale because the lender has to review the situation, approve the sale and agree to take less than the full payoff, and approval is never guaranteed.

What is the difference between a short sale and a foreclosure?

A short sale is a voluntary sale you arrange with the approval of your lender. A foreclosure is involuntary, when the lender takes the property after missed payments. Under Fannie Mae guidelines, the standard waiting period before a new conventional loan is four years after a short sale or deed in lieu, compared with seven years after a foreclosure.

How long does a short sale take?

Longer than a standard sale. After you find a buyer, the lender, and any second lienholder, has to review your hardship and finances, value the property, and approve the price before the sale can close. The timeline depends on the lender and how complete the file is, so starting early and having your documents ready matters.

Does a short sale hurt your credit?

Yes, a short sale affects your credit and your ability to buy again, but generally less than a foreclosure. The Fannie Mae waiting period for a new conventional loan is four years after a short sale versus seven after a foreclosure, and shorter waits can apply with documented extenuating circumstances. Other loan programs have their own rules.

Will I owe the difference after a short sale in California?

Often, no. Under California Code of Civil Procedure Section 580e, once a lender approves a short sale on a one-to-four-unit residential property, it generally cannot pursue you for the unpaid balance, and that extends to junior lienholders who consent. There are limited exceptions, such as fraud, so confirm your case with a California real estate attorney.

What should a short sale approval letter say?

It should state the amount the lender accepts, that the lender accepts it in full satisfaction of the debt, that any deficiency is waived for every borrower, and that the remaining balance will not be sold or assigned to a collector. Every lienholder on the property should sign off. The CFPB advises getting any deficiency waiver in writing and keeping it. Have a California real estate attorney review the letter before you close.

Do I have to pay taxes on forgiven mortgage debt in 2026?

It depends. The federal exclusion for forgiven debt on a primary home expired for debt discharged after December 31, 2025, unless the forgiveness was under a written agreement made before January 1, 2026. Forgiven debt can now be taxable, though insolvency and bankruptcy exclusions still exist, and non-recourse loans can be treated differently. Run it with a CPA.

Will I get a 1099-C after a short sale?

You may. When a lender cancels debt, it can file Form 1099-C with the IRS and send you a copy, even when California law prevents it from collecting the balance. Whether that canceled debt is taxable depends on the loan, whether it is recourse or nonrecourse, and exclusions such as insolvency. IRS Publication 4681 covers the rules, so have a CPA review your situation before you sign.

What is a deed in lieu of foreclosure?

A deed in lieu of foreclosure is when you voluntarily transfer the property back to the lender instead of going through foreclosure. It has to be approved by the lender, and any remaining debt should be addressed in writing. It is a direct conversation with your lender, alongside options like a loan modification, repayment plan or forbearance.

Should I sell now or wait if I am underwater?

It comes down to whether you have to sell or want to sell. If you do not have to sell, waiting, paying down the loan or renting the home can give the balance time to come down and the market time to improve. If you do have to sell, we work through bringing cash to closing, a short sale, or lender options.

Can I rent out my house instead of selling if I am underwater?

Sometimes. Renting can make sense if the rent covers most or all of the mortgage, taxes, insurance and expenses. It buys time for the balance to come down and the market to improve, but becoming a landlord comes with its own costs and tenant protection rules, so run the numbers honestly first.

What should I do if I am falling behind on mortgage payments?

Act early and talk to your lender. Options like a loan modification, repayment plan or forbearance, or a short sale approval, are far easier to get before you are deep in default. The worst case is falling behind, going silent, and letting the property move toward foreclosure without a plan.

Ryan Fisher, San Diego Realtor and founder of Lovery Real Estate

Ryan Fisher

Realtor · Founder, Lovery Real Estate

I am a San Diego Realtor and the founder of Lovery Real Estate, with $56M+ in career sales. I work with homeowners through situations where the path is not obvious and the stakes are high, across Chula Vista, Bonita, North Park, University Heights, Normal Heights and La Jolla Mesa, and throughout San Diego County.

Before real estate, I was drafted by the Miami Marlins in 2010 out of UC Irvine and went on to play professional baseball for six years. I grew up around Fisher Bros. House Moving, the fifth-generation California house-moving business my family ran from the 1850s, and worked in it myself before real estate.

Here are your options, here are the numbers, here is what I would do. No pressure. No sales pitch. Just results.

Want a clear look at where you stand?

Let’s run the real numbers on your home, privately and with no pressure, and build the plan from there.

Ryan Fisher, Realtor. California DRE #02110091. Lovery Real Estate is a brand of Ryan Fisher, licensed under LPT Realty. 323 Minot Ave, Chula Vista, CA 91910. This article is general information and is not legal, tax, or lending advice. Consult appropriate professionals of your own choosing.

(619) 651-9869